1989
Directed by Phil Alden Robinson
Distant Voices, Still Lives
1988
Directed by Terence Davies
As we get closer to the end of the List, the remaining titles tend to fall into two categories. One segment consists of films so obscure, they seemingly only exist on one film roll in Dawson City. The other category contains movies I am putting off because I have absolutely no interest in the subject matter (stay tuned!). This film falls into the former category, but I happened to stumble upon an online version. It reminded me that obscure movies are usually that way for a reason.
The movie focuses on a suburban working class family in 1940s Liverpool. It doesn't follow a plot so much as it flutters from memory to memory. The three siblings, Maisie, Tony, and Eileen, all experience abuse at the hands of their father, but they have different recollections of certain events. It's also not a musical per se, but music is a constant presence in the story, and seems to be the only source of a joy for a few of the characters.
This was a very odd movie that didn't quite settle with me. It felt very artificial to me, which is strange, because the movie was semi-autobiographical so you would think it would feel very real. I guess the style was so strange that it prohibited the actors from doing anything that felt authentic.
A non-musical musical I could have lived without.
RATING: **---
Interesting Facts:
Pete Poslethwaite didn't believe Terence Davies' father (on whom his character was based) could have been so vile to his family. Davies finally asked his sister to tell him about being beaten in the cellar by their father (as shown in the movie) that he accepted it was true. Um fuck you Pete. Why would you presume to know how much of a dick his father was?
The film had a very low budget and was shot intermittently over a period of two years.
Hana-bi
Fireworks
1997
Directed by Takeshi Kitano
Todo sobre mi madre
All About My Mother
1999
Directed by Pedro Almodovar
It's a shame that so many Pedro Almodovar movies have been cut from the List. I am really enjoying him as a director. I felt like he had a bigger vision for this film, even though it came before Volver.
Manuela is an Argentine nurse living in Madrid. She oversees donor organ transplants at a hospital, and is a single mother to Esteban, a teenaged boy who loves "A Streetcar Named Desire" a little too much. After a life changing night, Manuela travels to Barcelona where she reconnects with old friends and meets some unforgettable new faces as well.
Apologies for another vague description, but Almodovar tends to immediately throw the viewer into the action, which makes spoilers tough to avoid. I didn't enjoy this one quite as much as Volver, which I felt had more vibrant characters. But once again, Penelope Cruz left a strong impression and it was clear she has star quality.
All of the actresses involved gave great performances and it's nice to see more female-centric stories on the List.
RATING: ****-
Interesting Facts:
The movie is dedicated to Bette Davis, Gena Rowlands, and Romy Schneider.
All of the authors mentioned in the movie are famously gay writers.
Entre les murs
The Class
2008
Directed by Laurent Cantet
Jodaí-e Nadér az Simín
The Separation
2011
Directed by Asghar Farhadi
1200! Thankfully, we get to celebrate with the best movie I have seen in a long time. I watched this at approximately 3:30 am, because that's when my pain alarm clock woke me up. This proved to be a compelling watch that was able to distract me until pain medication kicked in.
The movie begins with Simin begging a family court judge for a divorce from Nader, who refuses to let her leave Iran with their eleven-year-old daughter Termeh. Nader doesn't want to leave his father, who is suffering from Alzheimer's, and won't agree to Simin taking Termeh away from him. The court denies her request, and deems the couple's problems unworthy of divorce. At this point, I thought this would be a story about an abusive husband, and a woman trapped in a country where she has very little rights. Instead, the plot shifts when Simin moves back in with her parents. Nader needs somebody to look after his ailing father, and employs Razieh, a deeply religious woman, who thinks washing a old man after he peed his pants is a sin. I suppose I will stop there so as not to provide any spoilers.
I think it is important that not every foreign film you watch be some gruesome tale about the local atrocities that took place there. While those stories are clearly important, they dehumanize the people living in those countries to some extent. We start to feel like they aren't really people, but just a collection of tragedies that we are helpless to fix. We get a plot here that doesn't revolve around war crimes, even if it does showcase some horrors of living in Iran.
I was really into this plot and it almost felt like Rashomon, with every character giving their side of the story and keeping the audience guessing. Highly recommended.
RATING: *****
Interesting Facts:
First Iranian movie to win an Oscar. The news of winning was mentioned only once on Iranian television.
Considered by Roger Ebert to be the best movie of 2011.
Jackie
2016
Directed by Pablo Larrain
I'm surprised that Natalie Portman didn't win Best Actress for her performance in 2016. I would think portraying Jackie Kennedy would be uniquely challenging, as we have so much footage to compare to Portman's performance. On the other hand, it probably gave Portman plenty to work with while researching the role, making it easier in some ways. She does a fantastic job of inhabiting the role of Jackie, even if I didn't love the movie.
The film focuses on the period immediately after JFK's assassination, when Jackie is coping with her husband's death. As her old life collapses around her, Jackie tries to protect her children and deal with her trauma.
God, being a First Lady would suck. You're just there for the photographs while your husband cheats on you constantly and men tell you what to do all the time. It would have been fascinating if the film went back farther into JFK's presidency, but this movie is about Jackie, so I understand why they chose the timeframe they did. It was moving watching Jackie attempt to make sense of things with the eyes of the world on her.
I actually thought the interview scenes with the journalist seemed out of character for her. She was much harder and more defensive in those scenes. I guess it just shows how the events of her life hardened and changed her. I enjoyed her conversations with the priest the most, when she was at her most vulnerable.
Definitely an Oscar worthy performance, I have words for the Academy clowns regarding this one.
RATING: ****-
Interesting Facts:
The only character that doesn't possess a real life counterpart is the priest.
JFK has about one minute and forty seconds of screentime.
Toni Erdmann
2016
Directed by Maren Ade
I have been complaining lately about the lack of comedies on this List. This is considered a comedy/drama, but I just read that the director doesn't think it's a comedy, and that she aimed to make it as sad and serious as possible. So it's a comedy, List stylez.
Ines works as a business consultant in the oil industry, and doesn't have much time for her family or a personal life. I know this sounds like the beginning of a romantic comedy, but it's not. Instead, the movie follows her relationship with her father, who decides to reconnect with her after years of semi-estrangement. After several failed attempts at connecting with Ines, her father decides to present himself as Toni Erdmann, and naturally Ines recognizes him immediately. However, she chooses not to let on, and in the course of doing so starts to let her hair down.
So the comedy here didn't really translate for me. I don't find pranks that amusing and if somebody ever jumped out on me from a closet when I thought I was alone, I would still be in the ICU. But as the director indicated, the comedy isn't really the focus of the movie. Instead, the relationship between Ines and her father takes center stage. It's really interesting watching the ripple effect of their relationship and how it influences other aspects of their lives in very strange ways.
And the naked party was strangely memorable.
RATING: ***--
Interesting Facts:
120 hours of footage was shot.
Maren Ade would typically do 20-30 takes of each shot, but sometimes took up to 60 to get it right.